D.R. Horton's financing banner for its Alabama communities uses a home priced at $339,058 as its example. With 3.5% down, an FHA 30-year fixed loan at 5.25% (5.959% APR) and a loan amount of $332,915, the banner puts the monthly payment at $2,232, counting taxes, insurance, mortgage insurance and HOA dues. The fine print says buyers must contract on or after October 17, 2026, and close by November 30, 2026, through DHI Mortgage. In the same week, the national average 30-year fixed rate in Freddie Mac's survey was 7.11%.
That gap of almost two points is the most useful number for anyone weighing a new house off Highway 69 South against an older one a few streets away. In 35405 this fall, new builds and resales sell in much the same price range. The difference between them is the cost of the money.
The price ranges overlap
D.R. Horton is building in four South of Town subdivisions. Sandy Pines, at 11661 Linna Lane off AL-69 South, starts at $245,900. Cypress Creek, at 4716 Henry Road, starts at $247,900, and its four listed homes run from $267,900 to $327,900. Parkway Gardens, at 9393 Parkway Gardens Loop, starts at $279,900, with listed homes up to $352,400. Tartan Cove, at 9291 Remington Parkway, starts at $334,900, with homes up to $394,900.
Lennar's Sandy Ridge, at Old Greensboro Road and Snapdragon Cove, advertises prices in the "Low $200k's," with posted homes from $236,900 to $311,079. Newcastle Homes' Havenridge has seven floor plans, asking prices from $299,900 to $419,900, and five quick-move-in homes in a new phase. Farther down the corridor in Moundville, Lennar's Cherokee Bend has plans starting at $222,650, and D.R. Horton's Glen Ridge starts at $329,900.
Resales in the same ZIP code sold for about the same money. Portal data for October 2026 put the median sold price in 35405 at $259,450, and a second portal's October figure was $259,867. Across the wider Tuscaloosa market, the Alabama Center for Real Estate reported that the median new home sold for $279,900 in July 2026.
That puts the lower half of the new-build menu within a few thousand dollars of the typical resale. A buyer comparing a three-year-old house on an established street with a new one at Sandy Pines or Cypress Creek is looking at similar prices. What separates them is the loan each one comes with.
The rate is where the money moves
Here is the same $332,915 FHA loan from D.R. Horton's example at two rates. Mortgage News Daily's FHA index stood at 7.05% on November 13. By our arithmetic, principal and interest come to about $2,226 a month at 7.05% and about $1,838 at 5.25%. That is a difference of close to $390 a month, or more than $4,600 a year, on the same house at the same price.
A price cut would have to be large to match that. Builders here are cutting some prices too: at Sandy Pines, D.R. Horton's home of the week at 11578 Shortleaf Lane was listed at $289,600, down from $307,600. That $18,000 reduction lowers the payment far less than the rate offer on a similar loan.
Lennar's version this month followed the same pattern with a different loan. Its Black Friday promotion advertised a 4.750% FHA 5/1 ARM (6.516% APR) with a sample payment of $1,085 a month for the first five years. That sample was based on a $171,259 home, so it is not a quote for any house in Tuscaloosa. The offer required Lennar Mortgage. The promotion page was filed under greater Birmingham, but its eligible homes included Sandy Ridge addresses such as 14399 and 14351 Bellflower Lane, plus two Cherokee Bend homes in Moundville. Havenridge advertised its own "3 Ways to Save" on three move-in-ready homes, ending November 30.
All three end within days of each other in late November. The two rate offers run through the builder's own mortgage company, and Lennar's and Newcastle's apply to move-in-ready homes, so each builder has its own approach to finished inventory before year-end.
These figures are general information, not financial, tax or legal advice. Rates and terms change weekly, so confirm your own numbers with a lender before you rely on any of them.
What the resale side shows
Builders paying down rates is one half of the market. The other half is what has happened to resale listings since rates went up.
A year ago, Freddie Mac's 30-year average was 6.24%. On November 12 it was 7.11%, even after four straight weekly declines. Over that stretch, resale homes in 35405 started taking longer to sell. Portal data for October 2026 put the median time on market at 65 days, up 58.5% from October 2025, with 353 active listings in the ZIP code. Another portal measured October at 72 days, with homes selling for 98.1% of list price and 133 sales closed in the month.
The countywide numbers point the same way. In July 2026, ACRE counted 916 Tuscaloosa-area listings, up 25.8% from a year earlier. That was 3.6 months of supply, compared with 2.7 months in July 2025, and ACRE puts the point where buyers and sellers have roughly equal bargaining power at about 6 months. ACRE's September summary, as reported by The Bama Buzz, put the metro median at $301,496 with 55 days on market and 956 listings.
Prices have held. The October median sold price in 35405 was up 1.75% from a year earlier. Time on market is what has stretched, in the same months that builders nearby were advertising rates below the market average. A buyer looking at a resale that has been listed for ten weeks in 35405 is looking at an ordinary listing this fall, not a problem house.
New homes are still a small part of total sales. In July, the 25 new homes sold in the Tuscaloosa area were 9.7% of residential sales, and new-home sales were down 56.9% from a year earlier. Builders are not taking over the market. Their incentives work on the margin, and South of Town has more active subdivisions than most parts of Tuscaloosa.
The deadlines are part of the pricing
Lennar's Black Friday window closes tomorrow, November 20, the last day to sign a purchase agreement, and those homes must close by November 30. D.R. Horton's rate and Havenridge's savings also end November 30. A buyer starting today would have 11 days to contract and close a home to use D.R. Horton's rate.
These particular offers matter less than how they are built. Each one has a short window, a closing deadline and a defined list of eligible homes. A buyer who knows that can treat a builder's sticker price and its financing as two separate numbers and compare each one against the resale down the road.
What is waiting in the pipeline
Most of the rest of South of Town's future supply is still waiting on approvals. Markwood Preserve, a 221-acre proposal at and around 6800 Hargrove Road East, would include 640 single-family lots, 203 townhome lots and two commercial lots. Its first phase was drawn with 137 single-family lots and 72 townhome lots on about 63.8 acres. According to the October 19 Planning and Zoning Commission agenda, the rezoning had not been recommended, the Phase 1 plat had been denied, and an appeal asked to return the proposal to a November agenda. Lennar's Kings Cove lists no homes available, with new homesites marked coming soon.
For a buyer, this means the subdivisions with move-in-ready homes this winter are the ones already selling. The larger roads and land-use decisions behind the next wave of building are the subject of our earlier post on South of Town's subdivisions and the road they are counting on.
Questions buyers are asking
Is a new build in South of Town cheaper than a resale? Often not on price. Several D.R. Horton and Lennar homes are listed within a few thousand dollars of October's 35405 resale median. The difference shows up in the monthly payment when a builder's financing is attached.
Can a resale seller match a builder's rate? A resale seller does not have a mortgage company. Resale homes in 35405 were taking 65 to 72 days to sell in October, longer than a year earlier, and that time on market is part of what a buyer brings to a resale offer.
Should I wait for the next builder promotion? This fall's promotions came with short windows and lists of eligible homes. Whether one fits you depends on the specific house, the lot and your timing, so compare it with the resale you would otherwise buy.
If you are weighing a new home off Highway 69 South against an older one nearby, we can put the two side by side, compare the monthly payment on each at today's rates, and show you how similar homes on that street have actually sold. Reach out to Caitlin Tubbs Wilson to talk through the South of Town homes you are weighing. Start Your Real Estate Journey.